Uninvited
Emotions, Taboos, and the Practice of Staying Close
This essay explores what usually goes by the name of “negative emotions”—anger, hatred, envy, grief—and what becomes possible when we meet them in stillness without rushing to solve them, suppress them, or put ourselves on trial for having them.
Consider the case of Jessica, an illustrative composite. For years she has written, organized, and stood in the cold outside embassies on behalf of prisoners held by a regime that tortures them. Lately something has shifted. She wakes at three in the morning composing arguments aimed at the man at the top. She rereads reports she has already read. The hatred she once felt in sharp, brief flashes now has a standing address in her body, and it has begun to wander. She finds contempt for neighbors who scroll past the news, for colleagues who attended one rally and drifted off, for allies whose commitment seems thinner than hers. Last week she snapped at her partner over nothing and could not say why.
Nothing in the scene settles what happens next. She may insist it is only the cause talking and that she is fine. She may let the feeling drive: quit, post something she will regret, cut off people she needs. She may numb it with work, wine, or the next crisis. Or she may set aside a bounded interval of solitude and let what is happening be felt without immediately discharging it into action. Some response will occur; even denial is a response.
Feelings of this kind arrive uninvited. No one decides to be consumed by hatred any more than to be seized by grief. They play out whether or not we approve, and we find ourselves in the middle of them. Moral, religious, and clinical authorities have long sorted these states into “positive” and “negative,” “healthy” and “toxic,” as if each emotion carried a fixed charge across all times and places. That picture does not survive a long struggle. The anger that gets someone into the street in February can, in March, be what pours onto a child at the dinner table. Worse, the very same surge of righteous indignation that puts civil rights marchers on the pavement can put neo-Nazis on the pavement too. The same holds for the states we praise. An unruffled calm—what the Greeks called ataraxia, the absence of disturbance—can allow one person to sit comfortably beside an injustice a few blocks away, and help another endure a storm. What a state does depends on where it is, what it is joined to, and how it is carried. Its value is contextual, not essential.
Page 1 of 7
Uninvited
I. Family Resemblances, Not Geometric Objects
Behind the habit of sorting feelings into “positive” and “negative” bins lies an older ontological assumption: that emotion words—hatred, envy, grief, fear—name discrete, tightly knit entities with clean boundaries and uniform internal properties, like the figures studied in geometry. If emotions were such objects, we could speak with precision of “gnawing envy at seeing the happy couple when he wanted the girl” as a finite, repeatable phenomenon, essentially interchangeable from one person and moment to the next.
Wittgenstein’s notion of family resemblances was fashioned precisely to break the grip of that kind of essentialism. Rather than define what all games have in common, he asks us to look at board games, card games, and ball games and see the similarities crisscross: “don’t think, but look!” What we call “hatred” or “envy” is likewise not a single inner mechanism stamped out identically across human beings; it is a loose, overlapping weave of bodily sensations, memories, appraisals, and action tendencies whose strands crisscross without sharing one invariant core. In that respect, emotional states resemble temperate seasons far more than geometric shapes. Everyone living in a temperate climate can distinguish winter, spring, summer, and fall, and those distinctions are real and useful. Yet though the calendar marks June 21 as the start of summer, it may be fifty degrees outside on that morning in New York. Ordinary speakers understand the elasticity of such qualitative patterns; distortion sets in only when we try to enforce geometric precision upon fluid processes.
This difference between the macro-label and the lived texture becomes obvious whenever we move closer to an experience. Seen from the shore at night, a string of lights across a suspension bridge appears as a single, continuous arc; walk onto the span, and the arc resolves into discrete bulbs spaced across steel. Swirl a lit cigarette in a dark room and it draws an unbroken glowing circle. Neither the arc nor the circle is an error that the close-up corrects; each is what the pattern is at that distance. Hold a crying baby and the generic category “crying” quickly gives way to idiosyncratic pauses, catches of breath, and shifts of the face that we would miss entirely if we remained spectators at a distance. So it is with emotion. From a distance, or in the heat of ordinary social exchange, “I hate” or “I feel gnawing envy” captures a real, recognizable pattern. Yet when we suspend the impulse to act or narrate our way out of the state and come into closer proximity with it, that seemingly monolithic block breaks into a shifting, idiosyncratic succession of sensations, images, and urges—tightness in the jaw, a flash of memory, the rehearsal of an accusation, the desire for the feeling to stop. No two people undergo that sequence in the same way. Essentialism loses its descriptive purchase the moment we look closely.
Page 2 of 7
Uninvited
Resisting geometric precision, however, does not mean surrendering to amorphous flux— as if human feeling were mere undifferentiated becoming with no recognizable structure at all. We do not need to settle ancient metaphysical disputes between being and becoming, or uncover what lies behind emotion “ontologically,” in order to describe lived experience faithfully. What matters for human interaction, communication, and self- understanding is not ultimate essence, but workable navigation.
Here Wittgenstein’s loose web can be given a more urban setting. Take a block in one of the city’s early-gentrification twilight zones, where longtime residents, artists, and newcomers overlap without a clean boundary. Late one night a shot rings out, and someone on the sidewalk screams. A visitor from a quiet town, lacking the city’s shock absorbers, may freeze or panic.1 Most of the people who live here will not. Years of sirens, crowds, and sudden noise have given them a habituated calm, a measure of ataraxia that is less a virtue than standard urban equipment.
Yet the block yields no single response. A couple of the braver ones run toward the person lying on the pavement. A woman stays where she is and calls for help, her voice steady. A lifelong New Yorker who jumps at a pin drop is shaking in a doorway. Two teenagers glance up, check that they are out of the line of fire, and go back to their cigarettes and conversation. When the police and EMS arrive, they bring their own mixture of concern, curiosity, compassion, practiced calm, and irritation.
The calm that steadies the caller’s voice is the same habituated calm that lets the teenagers walk on. The shock absorbers are shared; what is done with them is not. No verdict attaches to the callus itself, and perhaps another event would reach the teenagers differently; there is no need to condone or condemn in advance. We are only looking at the lay of the land. Things are all mixed up, but they are not chaos.
So it is with emotional neighborhoods. Tranquility, serenity, placidity, equanimity, patience: these are not walled boroughs on a cartographer’s map, nor random points scattered across a void, but adjacent blocks of the same city, each shading into the next. Overemphasizing their sameness flattens vital moral and practical differences; overemphasizing their difference turns fluid human patterns into rigid boxes. Pressed too hard, as Nietzsche warned of over-circulated coins, abstract labels wear their stamped faces smooth. Better to read the street signs lightly, knowing they mark shifting terrain rather than fixed essence.
Page 3 of 7
Uninvited
II. The Permission Slip and the Case for Bracketing
Why, then, do our institutions insist on treating fluid emotional weather as if it were fixed moral or diagnostic cargo? Partly because the old theological vocabulary never truly vanished; it merely changed its letterhead. While states like fear and anxiety are usually framed as unfortunate glitches to be calmed or cured, emotions such as hatred, envy, and stubborn grief carry a heavier moral stigma—making them even harder to sit with honestly.
Thomas Aquinas already recognized that the passions (passiones) are neither good nor evil on their own. Yet he immediately handed jurisdiction over them to a divinely ordered faculty of Reason, which alone could sign a “permission slip” for a person to feel anger or desire at a given moment—or issue an indictment of sin if the rational order was breached. Modern psychology and wellness culture claim to have secularized that framework, replacing spiritual vice with empirical measurement. In practice, they largely preserve the same permission slip under clinical jargon: dysregulated, maladaptive, toxic. Worse, affective neuroscience often rests on a quiet circularity—using natural-language self-reports as its indispensable ground truth to calibrate its instruments, only to turn around and treat promissory-note brain scans or diagnostic checklists as a higher tribunal entitled to overrule a person’s own account as confused or imprecise.
There is a philosophical case to be made against both Thomistic faculty psychology and scientized essentialism, and I have just sketched mine. Yet I own it plainly as my case, not as a deductive proof that settles the metaphysics of the soul or invalidates the convictions of readers who inhabit a religious or clinical worldview. Accounts of spiritual purity or psychological regulation may or may not capture something deep about human nature; how each reader ultimately settles those questions is their own affair.
What matters for our purposes is narrower and practical. Even within deeply traditional religious and contemplative lineages, practitioners have recognized the wisdom of temporarily bracketing those ultimate verdicts in order to become more intimate with what is actually happening in experience. Consider Psalm 137, kept in liturgical worship for centuries. It moves from weeping by the rivers of Babylon to a raw, uninhibited wish that the captors’ children be dashed against stones. Commentators have argued for millennia over what to do with that final verse, and I take no side here. Whatever else it is, it is hatred preserved in the canon rather than tidied away.
To sign a moral or clinical permission slip in real time requires slicing experience into fine second-order distinctions: Am I merely feeling this, or am I wanting it, willing it, consenting to it, thinking it? Pursued anxiously during quiet reflection, that audit replaces
Page 4 of 7
Uninvited
lived experience with a running courtroom transcript. It imports a teleological “Hereafter”—a future state of purity, regulation, or enlightenment—directly into the “Here-and-Now,” occluding what is actually present. Thomas Merton, in his late dialogues with Zen and his warnings against scrupulosity, saw this trap clearly: obsessive self- monitoring for inner impurities turns inward attention into a reflexive hall of mirrors, trapping the practitioner inside the ego’s own policing. Howard Thurman pointed toward a similar release in his practice of “centering down”—stilling the clashing traffic and external scripts so one can hear “the sound of the genuine” beneath them. Whether a reader later interprets their experience in theological, therapeutic, or wholly secular terms, suspending the audit for a time is what makes honest acquaintance possible in the first place.
III. Expressive Authority and Bounded Patience
Once we bracket external tribunals, where does authority over an emotional report rest? Here Emerson’s principle of self-trust and Wittgenstein’s account of first-person avowals converge. When someone says, “Ouch, my head hurts,” or “I hate,” or “I am envious,” that utterance is not an infallible theorem about deep psychological causes; it is an expressive, first-person report of how the world and the body show up at that moment. To demand that a sufferer consult an external expert—or a diagnostic checklist—before trusting their own avowal would make ordinary human experience unintelligible.
Honoring first-person authority does not mean pretending we never deceive ourselves. Jessica, snapping at her partner while insisting she is fine, may well be in denial. Yet even in an honest friendship or a good therapeutic conversation, an outsider’s doubt is never a dispositive verdict or a brain-scan proxy; it is only a fallible hunch, offered in dialogue, that lands only if the person themselves pauses and recognizes it. Inside solitary practice, we do not need an internal prosecutor cross-examining our reports for hidden motives. We simply start from the lived avowal as it arrives.
What, then, do we do when raw hatred, envy, or grief arrives uninvited and will not leave? In ordinary social life, feeling and action frequently fuse: we snap, march, retaliate, or reach for something to dull the ache. Those acts are part of the emotional storm, not separate events tacked onto a “pure” inner state. Contemplative practice introduces a different possibility—not by suppressing emotion, and not by retreating into political quietism, but by setting aside a deliberate, bounded interval apart from others in which the entire affective weather, including raw impulses to strike or flee, can be undergone without immediate execution.
Page 5 of 7
Uninvited
The old word for this capacity is patience, from the Latin pati—to suffer or undergo. In naming it so, I am not carving out a separate, virtuous “natural kind” walled off from serenity or urban composure. Like neighboring blocks that shade into one another, they share overlapping ground. Patience is not simply ataraxia, though it shares some of its stillness: it needs enough calm to stay put, joined to an even-minded alertness to what is going on and a measure of care. Nor is it polite resignation. It is the active, clear-eyed willingness to stay proximate to distress without having to discharge it at once. Even the urge to narrate our grievance—rehearsing the argument at three in the morning—can be felt as part of what is happening rather than used as an escape hatch from the body. Instead of forcing attention away from the story and onto the breath alone, one can let both stand together: the mind rehearsing its indictment, the chest tight, the body still breathing.
Because patience presupposes that measure of calm, it also has a threshold. When distress outruns the steadiness needed to stay with it, there is no longer patience, only being overwhelmed. That is why the practices that follow leave every exit open: declining the invitation, opening the eyes, looking around the room, or stopping are not failures of patience but respect for its conditions.
Nothing here guarantees less burnout, instant peace, or moral perfection. The claim is narrower. Uninvited, painful emotions will visit anyone who stays inside a long struggle or an honest life, and branding them essentially “negative” describes nothing real. Removing the taboo—and suspending the anxious audit of purity and pathology—allows us to undergo what is actually here, so that when the bounded interval ends and we step back into the world to speak, march, apologize, or rest, we act with our real condition in plain view.
Note
1 A note for the interested reader. The image of urban “shock absorbers” owes an obvious debt to Georg Simmel’s classic 1903 essay, “The Metropolis and Mental Life” (Die Großstädte und das Geistesleben), and his diagnosis of the metropolitan blasé attitude. For Simmel, the relentless, rapidly shifting nervous stimulation of modern city life—and, we might add today, its digital equivalents—forces the psyche to develop a protective callus, a dulling of sensitivity to sharp differences and sudden shocks, so that the individual is not overwhelmed at every street corner. Simmel largely refrained from moralizing this adaptation, treating it as the psychological price of urban individuality, and I follow him: when I speak of anesthesia or callus here, I mean equipment nearly every city dweller carries, not a moral slight.
Page 6 of 7
Uninvited
|
Seen through the lens of our emotional neighborhoods, the blasé sensibility is neither a single uniform condition nor an automatic moral verdict. It sits right alongside—and often shades into—what Hannah Arendt, in Eichmann in Jerusalem and The Life of the Mind, described as the absence of “thinking”: that internal, two-in-one dialogue of conscience that interrupts autopilot and refuses to sleepwalk through ordinary social scripts. Arendt pressed the moral weight of that absence hard, and rightly so in her context; I borrow only her picture of an inner dialogue that may or may not interrupt the routine. Crucially, Arendt’s “thoughtfulness” and “thoughtlessness” are no more a clean binary than Simmel’s blasé buffer is a pure natural kind. Walk through any dense modern neighborhood—or scroll through any contemporary feed—and you find varied degrees of cognitive and emotional buffering commingling on the same block. An awake urbanite does not react with the unbuffered startle of someone fresh from a quiet village; they still carry Simmel’s shock absorbers, habituated to noise, crowds, and constant stimuli. What varies is whether that buffer remains permeable enough for conscience and qualitative attention to register what is happening in front of them. Some inhabitants of the transitional zone pass by an event untouched; others remain raw, carrying visible wear and tear from refusing to look away; still others keep a steadier, clear-eyed composure— calm enough not to shatter or lash out, yet awake enough not to step over someone bleeding on the sidewalk. Like the shifting blocks of a city, wakefulness and callousness coexist in porous shades rather than neat moral compartments. |